Find Real Estate Agent AUAdd your business
← Back to Newcastle
Presence Property Management

Presence Property Management

4.5(479 reviews)See reviews ↓·Newcastle

What customers say

Based on genuine customer reviews

Presence Property Management is based on Telford Street in Newcastle East and holds a 4.5 average from nearly 480 reviews. Nathan Finney draws multi-year landlord loyalty — one dual-occupancy owner describes several years and four tenant changeovers of on-the-ball service — and Jules Byrnes is praised for market knowledge, competitive rates and hands-on coordination of a new build through to occupation certificate and leasing.

Tenants name Karlie Martine for approachable, prompt management. The feedback describes a communicative boutique operation focused purely on property management.

Real estate agent
Presence Property Management — Customer photo
Presence Property Management — Customer photo
Presence Property Management — Customer photo
Presence Property Management — Customer photo

Reviews

Reviews are taken from publicly available sources.

RE
Rachel Ellis27 July 2026

Wendy was absolutely amazing to work with throughout the maintenance process for our garage door. From the moment Wendy took over the maintenance request, she kept us informed every step of the way and genuinely went above and beyond to ensure everything was followed up promptly. Thank you, Wendy, for all of your hard work, professionalism, and support. We really appreciate everything you did and couldn’t recommend you more highly. Love, Tenants from Henry Street, Merewether x

MK
Michelle Kelso12 June 2026

Best property management company in Newcastle. After ten years with another company I switched and what a difference! I am confident that my property is being looked after by people who know their job and care. I don’t have to chase them up. Recently my tenants moved out after several years. Presence handled the task of finding new tenants quickly and efficiently. Jules deserves special mention. Easy to contact and always on the ball.

GT
Gwen Trigg25 May 2026

Our experience with leasing did not follow the usual protocol. Nathan listened to our needs and whilst still being compliant was able to help with the leasing of our newly purchased property. I would recommend Nathan to assist with your rental needs. Thank you Nathan

PW
P.L.I. Wimalaratne22 May 2026

Karlie Martine was our Property Manager at Presence. Karlie has been an excellent real estate agent throughout our tenancy. She was always approachable, responsive, and genuinely attentive to tenant needs. Whenever we required assistance, she acted promptly and handled matters professionally and efficiently. Her communication was clear, and she made the entire experience smooth and stress-free. We truly appreciated her support and dedication, and we would highly recommend Karlie to anyone looking for a reliable and caring property manager.

FM
farhad maleklou30 March 2026

Great work by Nathan Finney, Guy and the team in securing the right tenant and leasing our property in a relatively short timeframe. Their strong communication and persistence ensured an excellent outcome — one that genuinely exceeded our expectations.

NK
Nikki Keen20 March 2026

I had a really bad experience with my previous property manager, so I was quite stressed going into the change. Switching to Presence Property Management was the best decision I made. Nathan Finney and the team, especially Stephen and Steven , were fantastic throughout the entire process. They handle everything smoothly and found a tenant very quickly during a transition, which took a lots of pressure off me . The whole experience was professional , efficient and well communicated from start to finish. I really appreciate how helpful and responsive they have been. It such a relief knowing my property is being managed properly now . I highly recommend Nathan Finney and the team at Presence Property Management to anyone looking for a reliable and professional property manager.

IH
Izabella Holters12 March 2026

The best Property Management team I have encountered in 35 years of tenancy across three states. Efficient, prompt and empathetic are key words to describe Presence.

Property management in Newcastle compared

Ordered by rating, weighted by the number of reviews — businesses with only a handful of reviews do not jump to the top automatically. 4 businesses in this category in Newcastle are compared.

RankProviderRatingReviewsOpen Sat.
1Nisha Property Management★ 4,9188No
2PMC Property Management Newcastle★ 4,962No
3Newcastle Property Management★ 4,548No
4Presence Property Management (this page)★ 4,5479Yes
Contact
Working hours
Monday09:00–17:00
Tuesday09:00–17:00
Wednesday09:00–17:00
Thursday09:00–17:00
Friday09:00–17:00
Saturday09:00–13:00
SundayClosed